More Pages: Kent Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82


explains XP jargon, but doesn't support its assertions
OK. It finally made a book.
valuable for coaches; needs more valid research"presents many good challenges that need to be addressed"
"Questioning XP did not appear to be backed by enough meaningful research or experience to provide a truly honest critique of XP. Its conclusions did not seem to be in line with the evidence presented in the rest of the book. However, I do recommend it for XP coaches--it does provide a thorough awareness of the issues that will be faced on an XP effort."
A complete review is available at xprogramming.com.


A strange mixtureGramm's descriptions of historical events often left me wondering and in a few instances they are intentionally incomplete. Describing Lincoln's reaction when asked what he should do about slavery, Gramm says only that "Lincoln's dry and more or less sardonic reply is well know." Gramm doesn't tell me what it was and I don't know (p. 22 in the Indiana U. Press paperback). Elsewhere Gramm reports "'If I can't whip Bobby Lee with this,' said George McClellan, waving the copy of Lee's orders-but the rest of the story is well known." (p. 72) Not to me.
Gramm's approach to the history of the battle wobbles. Sometimes he writes straight historical detail: "For the Second [Wisconsin regiment], 302 present, 26 killed in action, 155 wounded, 52 missing: 233. . . . The Seventh, with 370 originally present, defended 35 yards, losing 39 killed, 103 wounded, 52 missing during the whole battle. During the war the 7th Wisconsin enrolled 1,714 men: 1,029 originally mustered in plus 685 recruits throughout its service . . . ." (p. 161)
Sometimes he indulges in careless approximations: After stating, "Gettysburg receives on the average 3, 018,123 visitors per year, who spend $81,077,687," Gramm astounded me by saying, "I have made these figures up, but they will do." (p. 2) If Gramm wants to make this point, why would he not go to the little trouble it would take to gather the data?
Sometimes he offers chat and speculation, perhaps intending to be witty or disarming: "maybe Archibald was a pain in the neck, a self-righteous, teetotaling ass" (p. 121); "that incredible jerk Kilpatrick" (p. 26); "Quite possibly Lee blew his cork, and Stuart cried" (p. 25); and regarding Heth, "Somewhere he had requisitioned too big a hat and had stuffed a wad of newspaper inside to make things fit, and the bullet's impact was cushioned by the newsprint. The moral is that it's good to steal hats." (p. 66)
At their best, Gramm's "meditations on war and values" are trite or puzzling: "The idea that voting is nonviolent is wistful; the physical violence is merely at one or two removes." (p. 29). "The battlefield itself is like a holy book., motionless yet always moving, palpable but always new. Similarly all the world: infused, shot through, with mystery, terror and beauty, changeless but changing as we are changing" (p. 45).
But often his "meditations" are attacks. Sometimes they are aimed at fundamental and evangelical Christians whom he calls "fundagelicals" (p. 121). An example: "Fundamentalists are sinister. Most American 'evangelicals' are fundamentalists who shop at Marshall Field's." (p. 242)
More often they are attacks on American culture and values.
"Today a young black man in an urban ghetto is worse off than his father or grandfather was. If you are poor, young and black you have as little hope as a slave had. . . . America is dying in the streets." (p. 23)
"We have been expending everything, and putting nothing of a moral nature back in. . . . Out goes the children's education, out go the poor, the homeless, the Hispanics and blacks, out go the old people, out goes Nature itself; out go Vietnam vets and 300,000 Iraqis . . . In come the Japanese." (p. 31)
"But now all the glory is spent, and America is a geriatric debauchee rolling downhill in a Japanese wheelchair." (p. 107)
"The New American Dream has become a cruel reality. . . . We are beyond all appeals to honor. We are about to be overwhelmed. . . . we don't believe in what we are doing." (p. 242)
To me, Gramm's ideas are tired, his insights are banal, and his ranting is mostly confused, stream-of-consciousness, self-indulgent ruminations woefully in need of a heavy-handed or even ruthless editor. Perhaps somewhere behind the jumbled gush of words there are fresh ideas that with more discipline and rigor could have been expressed coherently to readers.
I expected much better than this from a book about the Battle of Gettysburg and subtitled "meditations on war and values."
If the book is redeemed for me to any degree, it is largely by the essay on Dorsey Pender.
A Book With Feeling
Social Critique + Gettysburg? Yep- and it WORKS!Gramm attempts to show that we have squandered both the ideals and the dreams those men fought for through a combination of purposeful action and outright indifference. We have, he argues, fallen headlong into a morass of thoughtless materialism. The result of our tumble is an unforgivable lack of any sense of nobility in our society on either the collective or individual level. Whether or not one agrees with the author's conclusions, they are argued cogently and with tremendous passion, and are, at a minimum, quite thought-provoking.
Gramm's history is as well-done as his sociology, rendered in a semi-conversational style that is eminently readable, informative, and entertaining. His accounts of events and people from the Battle of Gettysburg are fascinating and spot-on, with the effect of making his social critique that much more moving (his brief study of Confederate general Dorsey Pender is especially effective in that sense).
"Gettysburg" is a brilliant book that not all will find to be such- if one prefers his history "straight up", Gramm's approach will likely be rather annoying. But for anyone willing to try history "with a twist", written from what is clearly a deep reservoir of feeling and experience, this book will prove to be a treasure.
At the very beginning of "Gettysburg", Gramm justifies his whole approach with a Thoreau quote: "...it is the province of the historian to find out not what was, but what is." Perhaps it is the province of the reader of history to do the same.


one word: L A M E
I have to agree with the other customer. This book is bad.
Great way to learn about Elvis

A well thought out, and well written book.
Adds depth and dimension to an already superb seriesAll those trends are at work in this installment. If your principal interest to Kent's novels is the sea battles and swordfights, you may want to give up on the series--or at least this piece of it. If you've stuck with the series because because you care about Bolitho and the other continuing characters, though . . . settle back and enjoy a deftly written story about love, loss, and second chances (punctuated by some 1st-rate sea battles).
Kent's Books are always good

Relentless Pursuit
Bring Richard back, Mr. Kent!
The Royal Navy and a Quasi PeaceAdam Bolitho is still in command of the frigate Unrivalled only now is dealing with ships packed to overflowing with Africans en-route to slavery and with North African pirates. Neither of these opponents are giving much concern to politicians and merchant bankers of Great Britain, except in so far as they are accumulating wealth from the transport and auction of slaves. The man in the street knows little about this and cares less.
It is this apathy of the public that the Royal Navy in general and Adam in particular must battle. It might be easy to die for your country when the enemy is French or Spanish, but when it is a slave runner, the concept becomes a little vague. Fighting in the Bay of Biscay is one thing, fighting in the Bight of Benin is something else entirely.
Kent creates the atmosphere of these times with great care. You are faced with seamen, tossed onto the beach without thought, after being through tremendous hardship and danger. You are also faced with the families that they had left behind and now must support in some form or fashion. Also, there is the aristocracy, both of society and the Royal Navy that must be maintained. These features never go away. One would think that the needs of the Naval aristocracy would decrease as the Navy shrinks - far from it!
Adam Bolitho is a complex man and as I learn more about him, I can see this. From a bastard orphan to a successful naval officer, we have seem him evolve. Yet he is still dogged by his origins - he has never forgotten the days as a youngster fending for himself as his mother became unable to care and support him.
This is a book without the flash and thunder of a fleet action. Now it is a series of actions between schooners and sloops and oared launches. Adam's ship is too big and powerful to be of decisive value except as a resevoir from which to draw men to man the smaller ships. It is this type of action that is honing the skills of the men of Unrivalled and preparing them for the ultimate combat with African pirates.
Throughout the book, we are reintroduced to charecters of the past, Thomas Herrick, Daniel Yovel, Graeme Bethune and others. We see an appearance by Richard's daughter Elizabeth as she starts to connect to Adam for after all, in spite of birth situation, he is her closest surviving relative and vice versa.
This book is a continuation of the Bolitho family saga. It continues to add to what we know of the family, even if it is only in small details, such as the name of Adam's mother. I found it thoroughly enjoyable and a fine addition to my library. I would recommend it to anyone who has read even a few of the preceeding books on the Bolitho family.


Save your money
"Nice" but breath is life I want more than "nice".
Wonderfully Helpful

Horrible for the beginner!
Almost the same as the Manual
This one gets a lot of use.

Publishers padding particularly poor
A good series gone bad
A preoccupied Bolitho

tess of the d'urbervilles
Interestingly verbose!
The most sensitive story about the feelings of a young woman

Engineer
A pretty good book
Different point of view
However, Pete's assertion that XP only works in a certain niche of possible project-types isn't supported in the book -- the assertion is made many times, but no real evidence is presented. Since there are many successful projects out there doing XP, the niche must not be as small as Pete says.
I agree with one point from another (not yet published) book on agile software development: XP can provide a great improvement in software quality in those companies that don't already have a good development process. If your company has a good development process with acceptible agility and good enough results, you don't need to change what you do.